County rankingMichigan

Michigan Deer Counties Ranked: Dickinson Leads the FDR Index, Clinton the Buck Index

Dickinson leads the provisional FDR Index at 68.1. Clinton leads Michigan's separate Buck Index at 91, and Ionia leads inside the Detroit and Grand Rapids metros at 82. Search every county and see why those rankings disagree.

68.1Dickinson County, provisional FDR Index

Dickinson leads Michigan's provisional FDR Index at 68.1, ahead of Delta at 64.1 and Genesee at 63.7. The Buck Index tells a different story: Clinton leads it at 91 while sitting fifteenth in the composite. Dickinson and Delta carry Buck Index scores of 42 and 32, so the county with the highest overall model score and the county with the highest Buck Index are different places. Jackson is the only Michigan county in the first ten of both lists.

KEY FINDINGS

  1. Dickinson, Delta and Genesee lead the provisional FDR Index. The displayed scores are 68.1, 64.1 and 63.7. The table keeps the published model order even where displayed scores tie.
  2. Outside the Detroit and Grand Rapids metros, Clinton leads the Buck Index at 91. Inside them, Ionia leads at 82. FDR names the leaders on each side of the line, and a big metro means a Census metro area of 1 million people or more.
  3. Clinton leads the separate Buck Index at 91. It ranks fifteenth in the composite. The measures answer different questions.
  4. Jackson is the only county in both top tens. It is eighth in the composite and ninth in the Buck Index order. The county finder includes all 83 Michigan counties.

Michigan county finder

Where does your county rank?

Derived FDR scores captured October 17, 2026. Both indices use a 0 to 100 scale. Equal displayed composite scores keep the published model order. Zero is a valid score; unavailable scores are marked Not rated. Counties that are mostly inside city limits show Not rated for the Buck Index. Counties marked metro sit inside a Census metro area of 1 million people or more.

10 of 83 entries shown

Michigan county rankings. Derived FDR scores captured October 17, 2026. Both indices use a 0 to 100 scale. Equal displayed composite scores keep the published model order. Zero is a valid score; unavailable scores are marked Not rated. Counties that are mostly inside city limits show Not rated for the Buck Index. Counties marked metro sit inside a Census metro area of 1 million people or more.
State rankCountyProvisional FDR IndexBuck Index
1Dickinson68.142
2Delta64.132
3Genesee63.775
4Oakland Detroit metro62.678
5Alcona62.245
6Livingston Detroit metro61.872
7Macomb Detroit metro60.374
8Jackson59.783
9Saginaw5861
10St. Clair Detroit metro57.968
Compare another state

01County comparison

Two Upper Peninsula counties lead

Dickinson is first in the published model order at 68.1. Delta follows at 64.1 and Genesee at 63.7, then Oakland at 62.6 and Alcona at 62.2. Dickinson's lead is the widest step in the first ten. Below it the scores sit close together, so neighboring rank numbers do not demonstrate a hunting advantage for one county over the next.

The Buck Index column separates two close composite neighbors, Arenac and Iron, much more clearly. They share a displayed composite score of 57.4 at eleventh and twelfth. Arenac's Buck Index of 57 places it forty-seventh in Michigan's Buck Index order. Iron's 31 places it seventy-sixth. If the Buck Index is your reason for comparing those two counties, the composite alone leaves out the distinction you came looking for.

Michigan's composite now includes a habitat component. It rates each county's share of public land against the other Michigan counties, and Dickinson and Delta score high on it. That helps explain why Dickinson and Delta lead the composite while their Buck Index scores of 42 and 32 place them sixty-eighth and seventy-fifth in the Buck Index order. The two columns are answering different questions within Michigan, not merely shuffling neighboring counties.

County rankingMichigan: the first ten counties
  1. 01Dickinson68.1
  2. 02Delta64.1
  3. 03Genesee63.7
  4. 04Oakland62.6
  5. 05Alcona62.2
  6. 06Livingston61.8
  7. 07Macomb60.3
  8. 08Jackson59.7
  9. 09Saginaw58
  10. 10St. Clair57.9
Provisional FDR Index. October 17, 2026 FDR snapshot. The county finder includes the full table and download.

02County comparison

Clinton leads one list; Jackson makes both

Clinton's Buck Index of 91 leads Michigan. Berrien and Kalamazoo share a displayed score of 87, Monroe displays 86, and Washtenaw, Cass, Branch and Ingham share a displayed score of 85. Wayne shows Not rated on the Buck Index because the model does not rate a county that is mostly inside city limits. Its composite score of 56.0 ranks twentieth. Clinton's composite score is 56.9, placing it fifteenth. A hunter investigating Clinton for big bucks should know that distinction before calling it the model's all-around leader.

Jackson has a different profile: eighth in the composite at 59.7 and ninth in the Buck Index order at 83. It is the only county in the first ten of both rankings. That makes Jackson a useful comparison for someone who wants both measures in view. It is not independent confirmation of hunting quality, since the Buck Index also contributes to the composite.

Two more comparisons show what one headline score misses. Eaton, Calhoun and Ionia all display a Buck Index of 82, yet their composite ranks are fifty-third, forty-sixth and sixty-seventh. Chippewa, Missaukee, Ottawa and Tuscola share a displayed composite score of 52.0, yet their Buck Index scores run from 25 to 70. Equal values in one column can sit beside a wide spread in the other.

03County comparison

Keep Michigan's harvest measures separate

The Michigan DNR harvest summary labels its totals as reported harvests. A reporting total and an estimate from a hunter survey are different measurements. Combining them into one continuous line can create an apparent change that comes from the collection method. The agency's harvest dashboard is the place to inspect reported totals by the selected season and geography.

The FDR table is fixed to the model output captured October 17, 2026. The composite remains provisional. Keep the DNR's selected season and reporting method attached to any harvest figure you bring into the comparison.

04County comparison

A county comparison worth making

Search the county where you hunt and compare it with Jackson or Clinton. Jackson represents overlap between the two leading groups; Clinton represents the Buck Index leader outside the composite top ten. If your county looks stronger in one column and weaker in the other, identify which question matters to your hunt before changing plans.

The acreage model does not grant access. A confirmed property in a county you know can be more useful than a higher county score attached to no available ground. Keep your observations from that property beside the county evidence so that a surprising result has to earn its place in your decision.

05Basis of this report

Sources and method

Michigan combines herd and harvest signals, Buck Index results, change over time, a roadway component and a habitat component built from each county's share of public land. Derived FDR scores, captured October 17, 2026. The composite is provisional. The separate Buck Index uses 2011 through 2025 big-buck history per estimated bow-huntable acre and a national comparison group. Neither scale represents a percentage chance of success. Mapped habitat acreage does not establish hunting permission.

Compare the other states in the FDR county report series.

NOTES AND SOURCES

  1. Derived FDR scores captured October 17, 2026. Both indices use a 0 to 100 scale. Equal displayed composite scores keep the published model order. Zero is a valid score; unavailable scores are marked Not rated. Counties that are mostly inside city limits show Not rated for the Buck Index. Counties marked metro sit inside a Census metro area of 1 million people or more.

Fully Drawn Research is an independent data analysis desk, not affiliated with any state wildlife agency, transportation agency, mapping provider or outfitter. FDR county scores and interpretations are independent analysis. A county ranking does not evaluate an individual property.

Keep reading

More Michigan papers →

FDR Scout puts county harvest history like this on the map of the ground you hunt. Open Scout →See the plans →

Cite this

Fully Drawn Research. "Michigan Deer Counties Ranked: Dickinson Leads the FDR Index, Clinton the Buck Index." FDR Working Paper 102, Oct 5, 2026. https://www.fullydrawnresearch.ai/research/papers/michigan-deer-county-rankings. Accessed Nov 10, 2026.

Data and charts from this page are free to use with attribution. See the Content Lab.

More in Rankings

See all 87 →
← Back to research