From 2017 to 2025, Washington's general modern firearm elk seasons put only Willapa Hills and Ryderwood among the top 10 units for bulls every year. Hunters lacking a special permit can use those two units as the most consistent places to find bulls, though consistency does not settle which offers the best odds.
IRepeat Leaders
Only Willapa Hills and Ryderwood Held Top 10 Bull Ranks Every Season
The Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife supplies these figures on its general-season elk harvest page for 2025 and earlier seasons' matching pages back to 2017. WDFW builds its estimates using required hunter reports rather than counts at check stations. For every game management unit we selected its modern firearm row and counted antlered harvest as bulls. The pages cover 116 to 122 units per season, while 124 units show up during at least one season.
Over the nine seasons Willapa Hills totaled an estimated 999 bulls, or 6.3 percent of the combined estimate of 15,801 bulls. Willapa Hills' yearly bull estimate spanned a low of 82 in 2023 and a high of 151 in 2020. Ryderwood's total came to 729 bulls. The leading ten units supplied 37.5 percent of the total bull estimate.
Six units each ranked among the top 10 by bull count in at least 7 of 9 seasons. FDR's Utah elk page identified 8 unit rows out of 37 that kept a top 10 bull rank each year during 2015 to 2024. Utah's table includes far fewer units and covers ten seasons against the nine seasons here. Washington's 2 of 124 therefore is not a like-for-like comparison.
IIAntler Rules
Leaders Include 3-Point Minimum Units and Spike Units Under WDFW Rules
WDFW groups bulls within a unit by antler points running from 1 point up to 6 or more. That breakdown puts two types of leading units together, with each unit's antler rule explaining the difference. eRegulations carries WDFW's 2026-27 hunting regulations, which WDFW's current big-game regulation page links to. Their general elk season listings place Willapa Hills, Ryderwood, Lewis River, Winston and Williams Creek under the 3-point minimum rule for modern firearm hunting. The same list makes Little Naches and Cowiche spike bull units, puts Naneum and Quilomene under true spike bull rules and allows any bull in Huckleberry. We reviewed the eRegulations and WDFW regulation pages on November 15, 2026. We checked the 2026 rules here, leaving 2017 to 2025 rules unchecked.
Those categories line up with the harvest figures. In nine seasons Willapa Hills, Ryderwood, Lewis River and Winston listed neither 1-point nor 2-point bulls. At Willapa Hills bulls carrying 4 or more points were 92.4 percent of the estimate, compared with 94.5 percent at Ryderwood.
Spike units show the reverse pattern. Of Little Naches' 505 bulls, 461 carried 1 point for a 91.3 percent share. At Cowiche the share was 85.4 percent, with 428 out of 501. Quilomene listed 408 bulls and Naneum listed 402, all with 1-point antlers. Those four units reached a top 10 rank in 7, 6, 5 and 4 seasons. Ranking by total bulls therefore puts 1-point bulls beside 5-point bulls.
Taking all unit rows together, 1-point bulls grew from a 23.9 percent share of the 2017 estimate to 37.3 percent in 2025. The share of bulls carrying at least 5 points dropped to 33.8 percent from 41.1 percent.
- 1 point
- 5 or more points
IIIHunting Pressure
Leading Units Ranged Between 4.1 and 13.1 Bulls per 100 Hunters
Bull totals leave hunter crowding out of the picture. For individual seasons WDFW lists rounded hunter totals, success and days per kill. FDR calculated the rates here, rather than using the success percentages WDFW prints. We summed bulls and hunters for each unit over the nine seasons before dividing. Anyone hunting several seasons appears in every season they hunted, making those hunter counts hunter-seasons. The combined rate per 100 hunters was 5.7 bulls.
Swipe table to see every column
| Unit | Seasons in top 10 | Bulls, 2017 to 2025 | Hunter-seasons, 2017 to 2025 | Bulls per 100 hunters | 1-point bulls (percent of bulls) | 2026-27 antler rule |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Willapa Hills | 9 | 999 | 7,640 | 13.1 | 0.0 | 3-point minimum |
| Ryderwood | 9 | 729 | 6,966 | 10.5 | 0.0 | 3-point minimum |
| Williams Creek | 8 | 746 | 6,465 | 11.5 | 0.3 | 3-point minimum |
| Lewis River | 8 | 615 | 15,016 | 4.1 | 0.0 | 3-point minimum |
| Winston | 7 | 549 | 6,975 | 7.9 | 0.0 | 3-point minimum |
| Little Naches | 7 | 505 | 11,891 | 4.2 | 91.3 | Spike bull |
Across the nine seasons pooled Willapa Hills produced 13.1 bulls per 100 hunters. FDR calculated that rate from the combined totals rather than averaging yearly rates. The unit averaged 849 hunters a season. Pooling all nine seasons gives Lewis River 4.1 bulls per 100 hunters. Its average participation was 1,668 hunters a season. Pooling hunter days and dividing by pooled harvest gives 41.9 days per elk for Willapa Hills and 135.2 for Lewis River. Each of the six leading units had only bulls in its modern firearm harvest, making the all-elk success rate and bull rate equal when calculated from those pooled totals.
Some units surpassed every leader in bulls per 100 hunters. Within the 85 units totaling at least 500 hunter-seasons, the rates per 100 hunters were 17.8 bulls at Puyallup (320 bulls from 1,800 hunters), 16.6 at Rattlesnake Hills (199 bulls from 1,196 hunters) and 16.0 at Issaquah (168 bulls from 1,050 hunters). Bear River's 14.1 rate (270 bulls from 1,915 hunters) exceeded all six as well. Mashel's 12.3 (369 bulls from 3,005 hunters) topped every leader except Willapa Hills. Puyallup made a top 10 rank in 3 seasons, Bear River in 2 and Mashel in 3. Neither Rattlesnake Hills nor Issaquah reached that rank in any season.
IVChanging Leaders
Three Established Leaders Declined 45 to 50 Percent as Spike Units Increased
The totals over nine seasons blur a divide. From 2017 to 2019 Williams Creek averaged 104.7 estimated bulls per season, dropping to 52.0 during 2023 to 2025 for a 50.3 percent decline. Lewis River dropped to 47.7 from 87.3 (45.4 percent), while Winston dropped to 40.7 from 75.3 (46.0 percent). Willapa Hills' decline was 12.3 percent, with Ryderwood down 11.5 percent.
The trend reversed at Little Naches, Cowiche, Quilomene and Huckleberry. The seasonal bull average climbed to 69.7 from 42.0 at Little Naches (65.9 percent), to 72.7 from 46.3 at Cowiche (56.8 percent), to 63.7 from 40.3 at Huckleberry (57.9 percent) and to 62.0 from 40.7 at Quilomene (52.5 percent). These averages cover three seasons, so even one poor year shifts them. Little Naches' 2017 total was just 26 bulls.
For all unit rows combined, estimated hunters dropped 20.6 percent between 2017 and 2025. That meant a fall to 27,522 hunters from 34,674. The bull estimate for 2017 was 1,673. In 2025 it was 1,681. The corresponding rate rose from 4.8 to 6.1 bulls per 100 hunters.
Our rule is to read the unit's antler rule in WDFW's current pamphlet first because legal bulls depend on the unit. Start with Willapa Hills or Ryderwood if you want a bull with 3 points or more on one side. Both kept a top 10 bull rank during all nine seasons while annual estimated bulls dropped just 12.3 and 11.5 percent, but check Lewis River, Williams Creek and Winston again before choosing. Focus your initial spike search on Little Naches, Cowiche and Quilomene where yearly bull estimates rose 52 to 66 percent.
VKnown Gaps
Harvest Totals Are Estimates and Only 2026-27 Antler Rules Were Checked
WDFW expands mandatory hunter reports into estimates of hunters and harvest, leaving ranks separated by only a few bulls open to change. In 2021 a tie between two units at 47 bulls put an 11-unit group among the top 10, since we credit ties for tenth place with a top 10 rank.
Only 2026-27 antler rules were checked above. Rules during 2017 to 2025 may have differed, which keeps these figures from showing whether elk, hunters or changed rules caused the rise in 1-point bulls. Check your unit's current pamphlet before hunting.
We excluded special-permit hunts, archery, muzzleloader and multiple-weapon seasons. Individual season pages omit between 2 and 8 units from the 124, and no omitted unit exceeded 13 bulls in any season when it was listed. That stays well below the top 10 threshold of 40 or more. Our database copy agreed with WDFW's pages for all 2,162 values checked for antlered and antlerless harvest.
NOTES AND SOURCES
- Source: Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife general season elk harvest reports, 2017 to 2025, one page per season.
- Also: WDFW's 2026 to 27 hunting regulations for elk general seasons, published on eRegulations and linked from WDFW's big game regulations page, read November 15, 2026.
- Scope: General season modern firearm elk harvest by game management unit, 2017 to 2025, with 116 to 122 units reported each season and 124 units in all. Special permit hunts and the archery, muzzleloader and multiple weapon seasons are not included.
- Method: Bulls are WDFW's antlered harvest estimates from mandatory hunter reports. Units are ranked by bulls each season, and a tie at tenth counts as a top 10 finish. Bulls per 100 hunters and days per elk are our arithmetic over the nine seasons pooled. Antler point classes are as WDFW reports them.
- Limits: WDFW harvest and hunter numbers are expanded estimates from mandatory hunter reports, not check station counts.
- Limits: Antler rules were read for 2026 to 27 only. Rules for 2017 to 2025 and season dates were not checked.
- Limits: Hunters are summed across seasons, so one hunter in several seasons is counted several times.
Fully Drawn Research is an independent data analysis desk, not affiliated with any state wildlife agency, transportation agency, mapping provider or outfitter. Fully Drawn Research is an independent data and analysis desk. This paper reports FDR's analysis of public agency data. Harvest figures describe animals reported or estimated as harvested, not population size, and reflect hunter effort and regulations as well as animal numbers.
Keep reading
FDR Scout puts county harvest history like this on the map of the ground you hunt. Open Scout →See the plans →