Working paperIdahoNew

Four Idaho Units Held Top 10 General-Season Elk-Bull Ranks All 26 Seasons

General elk bull ranks stayed top 10 through all 26 seasons in units 4, 6, 10A and 39. Over 2001 to 2025 unit 4 had 8.2 bulls per 100 hunters and unit 28 had 19.7.

FourIdaho units held a top 10 rank for general-season elk bulls in all 26 seasons, 2000 to 2025

Only units 4, 6, 10A and 39 stayed among Idaho's top 10 for general-season elk bulls through every season during 2000 to 2025. Their steady bull take means a hunter comparing them should look at rates alongside totals. At 6,158 hunters per season unit 4 drew the largest crowd and had the group's lowest rate. Over 2001 to 2025 it ran 8.2 bulls taken per 100 hunters compared with unit 28's 19.7.

ILong Run

Four Units Stayed Top 10 Through All 26 Seasons

We pulled the figures from the harvest statistics in the hunt planner published by the Idaho Department of Fish and Game and from the corresponding pages for earlier seasons. IDFG identifies mandatory reports of harvest, reports of big game mortality and records from check stations as its sources without specifying whether the results are counts or estimates. For each unit we chose All Weapons Combined and counted that row's antlered take as bull harvest. We included tenth-place ties among top 10 finishes. Ties at tenth place put 11 units in the top 10 in 2018 and 11 in 2021.

Over 26 seasons unit 4 led bull totals with 12,841. Next came unit 39 at 12,226 and unit 10A at 12,030. Together the four supplied 21.5 percent of all 217,985 bulls recorded in the unit rows. Unit 1's sole top 10 miss was in 2020 when it recorded 244 bulls and tenth place required 258.

Swipe table to see every column

UnitTop 10 seasons (of 26)2000 to 2008 (of 9)2009 to 2016 (of 8)2017 to 2025 (of 9)Bulls, 26 seasonsShare of all bulls (percent)
42698912,8415.9
392698912,2265.6
10A2698912,0305.5
6269899,7634.5
1259887,9853.7
22247897,5203.4
32A206866,8613.1
8A205786,5303.0
23189456,4403.0
28179626,0552.8
Units with the most top 10 bull seasons, with seasons by period and total bulls from the All Weapons Combined rows, 2000 to 2025.

On its Utah elk page, FDR found 8 units holding top 10 ranks through all ten seasons. On its Washington elk page, FDR found 2 through all nine modern firearm seasons. Idaho's rows pool all weapons, so these comparisons do not put the same hunts side by side.

IIMoving Ranks

Units 28 and 23 Lost Ground as 5 and 8A Rose

Units 28 and 23 finished top 10 through all nine seasons from 2000 to 2008. During 2017 to 2025 the tally dropped to 2 of 9 seasons for unit 28 and 5 of 9 for unit 23. Unit 28's average bull take declined modestly from 239.7 per season during 2000 to 2008 to 216.3 during 2017 to 2025. The decline was 9.7 percent while unit 23's seasonal average rose from 228.0 bulls to 265.2.

Making tenth place took more bulls. For 2000 to 2008 the average cutoff was 195.1 bulls. It reached 255.4 during 2017 to 2025 while the statewide sum from unit rows climbed from 7,633 bulls per season to 9,114 for a 19.4 percent gain. Unit 5's seasonal bull average climbed from 112.3 to 269.7 for a 140.1 percent gain and unit 8A rose from 195.9 bulls to 314.0. Unit 5 had 0 seasons ranked top 10 during 2000 to 2008 and 5 during 2017 to 2025.

IDFG's combined rows supplied those early figures. In 2000 to 2002 those rows list fewer bulls than the sum of the take method rows. Using the method rows gives a 14.0 percent statewide rise, an early cutoff averaging 201.8, top 10 finishes for unit 28 in 8 of the early 9 seasons, an 8.6 percent bull increase for unit 23 and a 54.3 percent increase for unit 8A. We take that to mean a unit's rank by bull total depends on the rest of the state, so look at its own bull take before ruling it out.

Figure 1 · Bulls by seasonBulls per season in units 28, 23, 8A and 5
  • Unit 28
  • Unit 23
  • Unit 8A
  • Unit 5
2000200820172025
Bulls per season in units 28, 23, 8A and 5 from IDFG's All Weapons Combined rows, 2000 to 2025.

IIIHunter Pressure

Unit 4 Leads Hunter Counts With 8.2 Bulls Taken per 100

A bull total leaves crowding out of the picture. For every unit we divided the bulls by the hunters after pooling both over seasons with hunter counts printed by IDFG. Because IDFG listed no hunters for 2000 the rates span 2001 to 2025. Our cutoff kept small units out by requiring a total of 10,000 hunters and 20 seasons showing hunter counts. That left 53 of 99 units. The floor reflects our choice, with unit 22 ranked 5th of 29 using 20,000 hunters and 16th of 79 using 5,000. Pooling all unit rows gave 10.8 bulls taken per 100 hunters.

Swipe table to see every column

UnitBulls per 100 huntersAll-elk success (percent)Hunters per seasonTop 10 seasons (of 26)
21A23.425.76851
2819.722.31,20017
1719.019.25121
1418.824.59662
2214.618.72,02324
10A13.718.03,41826
3912.513.83,76226
612.116.63,15526
48.210.46,15826
18.211.43,83025
Bulls per 100 hunters and all-elk success from pooled hunters and harvest, 2001 to 2025, for the four highest rates, the four steady units, unit 22 and unit 1.

Across 25 seasons unit 4's 153,952 hunters were the most for any unit. Its rate placed 39th of the 53. Unit 1's rate also came to 8.2 bulls taken per 100 hunters. With 1,200 hunters per season unit 28's rate was 19.7, or 2.4 times unit 4's rate. Unit 28 earned top 10 finishes in 17 seasons. Unit 22's 14.6 came with 24 seasons ranked top 10 while unit 10A's 13.7 came with 26. From 2009 to 2016 unit 22's rate was 17.6 before dropping to 12.2 during 2017 to 2025. Unit 28 ran 21.5 in that later stretch.

The rates in units 21A, 17 and 14 beat those in every steady leader. Their top 10 season counts were 1, 1 and 2.

IVBull Antlers

Spikes Took a Larger Share in All Four Consistent Leaders

IDFG lists %Spike and %6+Pts as its two antler columns. FDR reads these columns as the shares of a unit's recorded bulls (the antlered harvest) that were spikes and that had 6 or more points. To avoid mixing take methods we used combined rows alone. IDFG printed the columns in 21 of 26 seasons with coverage of some or all units. Those columns cover 84.1 percent of all 217,985 bulls.

For all units the spike share was 26.4 percent and the share with 6 points or more was 28.5 percent. The four steady units pooled together came to 33.1 and 20.7. For seasons with IDFG's antler columns the spike and 6-or-more shares were 36.6 and 15.6 for unit 10A, 33.1 and 19.3 for unit 6, 32.3 and 24.6 for unit 39 and 30.5 and 22.7 for unit 4. Among the 22 units with coverage of at least 3,000 bulls unit 76 led the share carrying 6 points or more at 47.3 percent. Unit 5 trailed them all at 9.0 percent.

Our rule is to start your general-season bull search in unit 10A based on recent seasons. Seven units reached top 10 during at least 8 of those 9 seasons in 2017 to 2025. Unit 10A led that group with 13.0 bulls taken per 100 hunters compared with 10.7 for all units over those seasons. Bulls carrying 6 points or more made up just 14.2 percent of unit 10A's bull take compared with 29.3 percent in all units. If rate matters more than steady top 10 finishes, unit 28 had a pooled rate of 21.5 bulls per 100 hunters during 2017 to 2025 but made the top 10 in only 2 of those 9 seasons.

VSeparate Hunts

Controlled Hunts Total 52,115 Bulls Led by 66A and 76

We kept controlled hunts apart. Of the 284 hunt numbers, 257 appear with different area codes or boundary text across seasons. Those numbers do not track a fixed area so we added the antlered figures from every hunt row. The total over 26 seasons was 52,115 bulls.

Hunts with boundary text reading "all of Units 66A and 76" accounted for 5,262 bulls across 26 seasons. This was 10.1 percent of controlled bulls and the largest total for any boundary wording. Hunts whose boundary text specifies all of one unit accounted for 27,463 bulls. The leading totals were 2,556 in unit 29, 2,513 in unit 13 and 2,495 in unit 49. These totals offer no information on the chance of drawing.

VIRecord Gaps

Three Early Seasons and Missing 2010 Figures Weaken Some Results

For 2000 to 2002 adding the take method rows gives a higher bull total than using the combined rows. For 2000 the comparison is 6,362 against 5,256. The 2010 combined rows lack antlered values. We substituted method rows in 255 of 2,484 unit-seasons. All four steady units stayed top 10 with either measure. We left out any row showing harvest without an antlered or antlerless figure when counting bulls. Hunter totals in combined rows sometimes differ from those in the method rows.

Eleven unit codes do not appear on every page. None exceeds 53 bulls in a season where it appears. Every code appears by 2000, although a page alone does not reveal whether IDFG changed a boundary while keeping its code. The rates show past results without testing their causes. Idaho's tag and zone rules were outside our check. Our stored database copy agreed with the pages for every one of the 20,208 values we checked.

NOTES AND SOURCES

  1. Source: Idaho Department of Fish and Game hunt planner harvest statistics, general and controlled elk seasons, 2000 to 2025, one page per season.
  2. Scope: General-season elk harvest by unit from IDFG's All Weapons Combined rows, 2000 to 2025, with 99 unit codes. Controlled hunt rows are summed separately by the boundary text IDFG prints. Rates cover 2001 to 2025.
  3. Method: Bulls are IDFG's antlered harvest on each unit's All Weapons Combined row, with the take method rows added together where that row prints no antlered or antlerless number. Units are ranked by bulls each season, and a tie at tenth counts as a top 10 finish. Bulls per 100 hunters and pooled success are our arithmetic over the seasons with hunters printed, for units with at least 10,000 hunters and 20 such seasons. Spike and 6 or more point shares are IDFG's columns, weighted by each unit's bulls. Our copy of the data matched IDFG's pages on all 20,208 values compared.
  4. Limits: IDFG says its statistics rest on mandatory harvest reports, big game mortality reports and check station records, but its pages do not say whether the figures are counts or estimates.
  5. Limits: In 2000 to 2002 the All Weapons Combined rows show fewer bulls than the take method rows added together, and the 2010 combined rows print no antlered numbers. The take method rows fill 255 of 2,484 unit-seasons.
  6. Limits: IDFG's pages print no hunter numbers for 2000 and leave hunters blank for some units in later seasons, so rates use only the seasons with hunters printed.
  7. Limits: Controlled hunt numbers do not stay with one area from season to season, so controlled totals are summed by the boundary text IDFG prints.
  8. Limits: Idaho's elk tag and zone rules were not checked.

Fully Drawn Research is an independent data analysis desk, not affiliated with any state wildlife agency, transportation agency, mapping provider or outfitter. Fully Drawn Research is an independent data and analysis desk. This paper reports FDR's analysis of public agency data. Harvest figures describe animals reported or estimated as harvested, not population size, and reflect hunter effort and regulations as well as animal numbers.

Keep reading

More Idaho papers →

FDR Scout puts county harvest history like this on the map of the ground you hunt. Open Scout →See the plans →

Cite this

Fully Drawn Research. "Four Idaho Units Held Top 10 General-Season Elk-Bull Ranks All 26 Seasons." FDR Working Paper 262, Nov 15, 2026. https://www.fullydrawnresearch.ai/research/papers/idaho-elk-units-that-keep-leading. Accessed Nov 21, 2026.

Data and charts from this page are free to use with attribution. See the Content Lab.

More in Rankings

See all 89 →
← Back to research