Estimated damage to crops in Poland was about 30 percent lower in years with plentiful oak seed than in years when the oak seed crop failed. We think US landowners whose corn gets hit by hogs and deer could watch acorns for an early warning of pressure on fields. The study covered only red deer and wild boar in Poland.
IHeavy Acorn Crops
Polish Crop Damage Estimates Fell About 30 Percent With Plentiful Acorns
The work from Bogdańska, Journé and Bogdziewicz appeared on EcoEvoRxiv as a preprint and has received no peer review. The national data from 2001 to 2020 include oak seed production, wild boar and red deer numbers, and the area of damaged farm crops. Their estimate puts the decrease in damage at 30% between failed seed crops and abundant ones. They propose that plentiful acorns draw animals away from crops by changing what they eat.
The figure shows the model's predictions. When oak seed production was low the model for wild boar put damage at about 1,828 hectares compared with about 1,295 hectares when production reached its maximum. The decrease works out to about 29%. For red deer the predicted area fell from about 2,977 hectares to about 1,828 hectares. That decrease comes to about 38%. Each prediction holds the model's other conditions at their averages. In the preprint both the low-oak prediction for boar and the maximum-oak prediction for red deer carry an identical figure of about 1,828 hectares. The authors summarize the decline as 30%, between those percentages. Whether the predictions describe the whole country or individual regions is left unstated in the preprint. The caption for Figure 1 calls the damage figures regional means, which leads us to interpret them as values per region.
IITracking Field Loss
Records Measured Damage in Hectares Throughout 16 Polish Regions
The damage figure is hectares of damaged crop area adjusted for how much was destroyed. Within a region and season the damaged acreage is multiplied by the share destroyed, meaning a field with half its crop gone contributes half its area. The Polish Hunting Association supplied these records through its Czempiń research station using association divisions' annual reports. Coverage includes Poland's 16 regions called voivodeships and 19 hunting seasons running from 2000/2001 through 2019/2020. The damaged area climbed from less than 1,000 hectares in 2001 to roughly 2,500 hectares in 2020. The same caption leads us to treat those figures as averages per region too.
The public dataset MASTREE+ supplies the oak seed records. It draws on a long-term monitoring effort started in 1954. Seed production in 17 State Forests regional divisions is expressed as the percentage of trees reproducing within a population. The oak category combines the two species Quercus robur and Quercus petraea. The share of oak trees producing seed varied between years with a standard deviation of 17 percentage points.
Counts of red deer and boar come from hunters' observations throughout the year totaled within each region, which the association uses when setting yearly hunting plans. The authors applied a one-year lag to both seed crops and animal counts so seedfall precedes the hunting season running from April 1 through March 31.
IIISeparate Species Models
Red Deer Had the Larger Decline and Animal Counts Had More Pull
A mixed model used log-transformed damage and gave region a random intercept, preserving a separate baseline for every region. Strong correlation between the species' counts led the authors to fit a separate model for each species (r = 0.68 over the full period). They scaled oak seed production and animal counts before fitting the models.
Swipe table to see every column
| Model and period | Oak estimate (SE) | Beech estimate (SE) | Beech p |
|---|---|---|---|
| Boar, full period | -0.07 (0.02) | 0.03 (0.02) | 0.24 |
| Red deer, full period | -0.10 (0.02) | 0.01 (0.02) | 0.64 |
| Boar, before African swine fever | -0.05 (0.01) | -0.03 (0.01) | 0.02 |
| Red deer, before African swine fever | -0.09 (0.02) | 0.01 (0.02) | 0.72 |
Animal counts changed predicted damage much more than acorn crops did. With few boar the prediction was about 452 hectares versus about 1,925 hectares with many boar, putting the higher figure above three times the lower figure. For red deer the prediction rose from about 224 hectares at minimum abundance to about 6,135 hectares at maximum abundance, over twenty times the lower figure. The authors describe animal abundance as the strongest influence pushing damage upward.
After 2014 African swine fever sharply reduced boar numbers. The oak relationship remained when the authors restricted their analysis to seasons preceding the first known outbreak during the 2014/2015 hunting season, producing estimates of -0.05 (SE 0.01) for boar and -0.09 (SE 0.02) for red deer.
IVBeech Seed Results
Crop Damage Had No Clear Connection With Beech Seed
Neither model covering the full period found a significant effect of beech seed production on damage to crops. The beech coefficient for boar came to 0.03 (SE 0.02, p = 0.24). For red deer it came to 0.01 (SE 0.02, p = 0.64). The authors offer beechnuts' smaller size and lower nutritional value compared with acorns as a possible explanation. They also propose that correlated production of oak and beech seed (r = 0.28) may have hidden an independent beech effect.
The supplementary table contains a detail left undiscussed in the text. Restricting the boar model to seasons preceding African swine fever gave a beech coefficient of -0.03 (SE 0.01, p = 0.02). This negative estimate points the same way as the oak relationship and is one of four estimates for beech. The remaining three p-values were 0.24, 0.64 and 0.72. We consider the evidence for beech unresolved, while oak has the preprint's support.
VWatching US Crops
Whitetails and Feral Hogs Remain Untested but Acorns Merit Attention
All these findings come from Poland. Neither whitetails nor US records were included in the study. We think similar reasoning could apply to deer and hogs feeding in US fields, though that possibility went untested here.
FDR examined a different measure in its Missouri acorn paper. In Missouri's counties with the most woods the registered deer kill increased during the 2023 to 2024 season following a poorer acorn crop and decreased during the 2024 to 2025 season following a heavy crop. That work tracked harvest rather than damage to crops. We see both findings as consistent with acorns changing animals' feeding locations, though neither establishes that relationship in US crop fields.
Failures of white oak and red oak crops can occur in separate years, an important distinction when checking acorns. FDR explains the acorns deer chose first during Georgia trials in its white oak and red oak guide.
Our rule is to check the acorn crop on oaks near a crop field in late summer while acorns still hang from the twigs. FDR's guide places that check in mid to late August. When acorns hang on few trees, give that field more frequent checks and first priority for protection. We apply that thinking to food plots too, an extension this study left untested. Plenty of acorns gives some reason to hope field pressure will ease but offers no guarantee, because animal counts had a stronger connection with Polish damage than acorn crops did.
VIStudy Boundaries
A Single Polish Preprint Shows Associations
Peer review has not taken place for this version 1 preprint. Its observational design connects oak seed crops with damage through an association. With no diet records available the authors could not directly measure their proposed change in feeding. The authors acknowledge biases in hunters' counts of red deer and boar, which prevented a test of animal numbers' response to seed crops.
The preprint leaves the number of records used in its models unstated. It also leaves unclear whether the hectare values describe individual regions or the country, leading us to interpret them as figures per region. Boar numbers changed with African swine fever after 2014, and a formal comparison before and after was beyond what the authors could run. Poland's forests, crops, boar and red deer differ from US country inhabited by whitetails and feral hogs. Our rule for watching fields went untested throughout the study.
NOTES AND SOURCES
- Source: Bogdańska, Journé and Bogdziewicz, Acorn availability reduces agricultural damage by ungulates, a preprint posted on EcoEvoRxiv that has not been peer reviewed.
- Scope: Poland's 16 regions over 19 hunting seasons, 2000 to 01 through 2019 to 20. Crop damage by wild boar and red deer, oak and European beech seed production, and hunter counts of both species.
- Method: Figures are as printed in the preprint. The authors fit separate wild boar and red deer models of log-transformed damaged crop area with region as a random intercept. The preprint does not say whether its hectare figures are national or per region, and we read them as per-region values.
- Limits: Preprint, not peer reviewed.
- Limits: Poland only.
- Limits: Observational.
- Limits: Unit scope of predicted hectares not stated.
- Limits: Number of model records not printed.
- Limits: Hunter-based animal counts biased per authors.
Fully Drawn Research is an independent data analysis desk, not affiliated with any state wildlife agency, transportation agency, mapping provider or outfitter. Fully Drawn Research is an independent data and analysis desk. This paper summarizes published research and adds FDR's reading of what it means for hunters. Figures are quoted from the studies linked in the text, and figures we computed from them are labeled as ours.
Keep reading
FDR Scout puts research like this on the map of the ground you hunt. Open Scout →See the plans →