Many hunters have left a dead quiet morning after the opener convinced the birds had left the farm. In South Dakota's Black Hills listeners heard as many males on hunted ground as on unhunted ground, but the hunted ground had less gobbling. Georgia and South Carolina recorders picked up far fewer gobbles on hunt days than on other days, and rain had the largest weather effect they measured. Rank your mornings by hunting pressure first and rain, barometric pressure and wind second. Leave quiet ground in your rotation.
IMorning Choices
Dry mornings with rising barometric pressure had the most gobbling
In Ecology and Evolution Wightman and colleagues used recorders on five public and federal properties in South Carolina and Georgia from 2014 to 2018. The units recorded from 1 March to 31 May and captured 194,655 confirmed gobbles.
Rain had the largest effect among the weather terms in that study. The model estimated a mean of 21 expected gobbles a day without rain and 12 with rain, about 43 percent lower by our arithmetic. The authors note that rain also muffles recorders, so some of the drop likely came from birds whose gobbles went unrecorded.
On the paper's standardized scale the estimates below rank the four terms rather than count gobbles.
Swipe table to see every column
| Weather term | Gobbling went | Paper's estimate |
|---|---|---|
| Rain | Down | negative 0.56 |
| Barometric pressure higher than the day before | Up | positive 0.28 |
| Warmer temperature | Down | negative 0.21 |
| Stronger wind, largest effect above about 6 mph (10 km/h) | Down | negative 0.16 |
That study found no clear humidity effect. In the International Journal of Biometeorology Palumbo and colleagues found in a 2008 and 2009 statewide Mississippi survey that gobbling was more frequent on dry days with lower humidity.
Southeast gobbling has a rough heat threshold. Colbert's University of Georgia thesis used recorders on two southwest Georgia sites in 2011 and 2012. On those sites gobbling peaked on days averaging 59°F (15°C) and dropped above about 70°F (21°C).
IIHunted Ground
A South Carolina area was almost silent on hunt days
In the Journal of Wildlife Management Wightman and colleagues set 45 recorders on three South Carolina properties in 2015 and 2016. Crackerneck was one of them and had hunting only on Fridays and Saturdays. Its mean daily gobble counts broke out this way.
Swipe table to see every column
| Crackerneck | Hunt days | Days without a hunt |
|---|---|---|
| 2015 | 9 | 91 |
| 2016 | 23 | 74 |
Georgia tells a similar story. Wakefield and colleagues matched 13,177 recorded gobbles to data from 82 hens and daily harvest reports in Georgia's Piedmont in 2017 and 2018. Daily gobbling fell more with hunting and the removal of males than it rose with hens laying and incubating. Wakefield's University of Georgia thesis predicted a drop in daily gobbling by a factor of 3.7 with hunting activity on those two hunted areas. There the calendar overlaps with hunting pressure and they cannot be cleanly separated.
Both states had more gobbling on unhunted ground than hunted ground. Only a 2-day hunt for mobility-impaired hunters was allowed at the Savannah River Site. Compared with that site Crackerneck had 27 percent less gobbling and the Webb complex had 45 percent less. In southwest Georgia Colbert found the unhunted Jones Center recorded about 32 and 44 percent more gobbles than Silver Lake WMA from the Silver Lake general opener to the end of the breeding season.
The South Carolina authors said the unhunted site may simply have had more gobblers. In 2015 the Webb complex showed no hunt day split. Daily hunter numbers were also not a useful predictor in their best model. Colbert's models did not detect a clear effect of hunting.
On the Webb complex in 2015 and 2016 Chamberlain and colleagues wrote in the Wildlife Society Bulletin that gobbling did not rise as hens began incubating. On their South Carolina sites in 2015 and 2016 Wightman and colleagues found under 44 percent of gobbling came within the legal season and 30 to 48 percent came after the season closed.
IIIQuiet Birds
Hunted ground was quieter with as many males heard
In the Proceedings of the National Wild Turkey Symposium Lehman and colleagues used listening routes for Merriam's turkeys in South Dakota's southern Black Hills in 2003 and 2004. The hunted route was in Black Hills National Forest and the unhunted route was in Wind Cave National Park. Before the season the routes were similar at 5.25 and 5.01 gobbles per male or male group. During the season the hunted route dropped to 4.56 compared with 7.01 on the unhunted route. Neither year showed a difference between routes in the number of males heard.
Gobbling nearly stopped at some South Carolina recorders when the season opened and rose again after it closed. Every site also had stretches of quiet at single recorders with hunters or without them.
Most gobbles were recorded around first light. At the Savannah River Site and Crackerneck 72 to 84 percent of gobbling fell between 30 minutes before and 60 minutes after sunrise. In the Georgia Piedmont 72 percent fell within an hour of sunrise. The South Carolina authors wrote that males on the hunted sites gobbled essentially only from the roost or soon after they left it. The Wakefield thesis model also found that a lighter gobbling day tended to follow a heavy one.
IVNorthern Evidence
Midwest hunters rely on Southeast recorder counts
All the recorder studies here come from Georgia or South Carolina. Evidence from the north comes from Black Hills counts by ear and an older south-central Iowa study from 1978 to 1981 that we could view only as a library abstract. Lehman and colleagues cite that Iowa study by Kienzler and colleagues for a drop in gobbling once the season opened. Wightman and colleagues cite it for more gobbling as temperatures rose farther north and suggest the penalty on warm mornings may not apply there.
Those Black Hills routes cannot answer the weather question because crews skipped mornings with rain, snow or wind of 16 km/h (about 10 mph) or more.
VMorning Picks
Rank hunting pressure before you score the weather
Our rule is to rank the coming mornings this way from a Thursday night forecast.
Start by sorting mornings by hunting pressure on the ground you plan to hunt. Ground that has not opened yet or a day when nobody else hunts it goes in the top group. The first week after that ground opens goes in the middle group. Later weeks of steady hunting go in the bottom group.
Next rank the mornings within each group by weather. A dry night and a dry first light earn 3. Overnight rain or rain at dawn earns 0. Barometric pressure above the previous morning earns 2. Flat barometric pressure earns 1 and falling barometric pressure earns 0. Wind below 6 mph at dawn earns 1. In the Southeast favor the cooler morning when scores tie. Farther north leave temperature out.
Do not let a high weather score lift a morning above one with less hunting pressure.
Our rule sets the points at 3, 2 and 1. They are based on a 2014 to 2018 recorder study on five Georgia and South Carolina sites, where our arithmetic puts the rain estimate at 3.5 times the wind estimate and a rise in barometric pressure at 1.75 times. Our read is to sort by hunting pressure first. In that study rain lowered expected gobbles from 21 to 12 a day, and a Georgia thesis model put gobbling 3.7 times lower with hunting under way. These came from different models, so treat the gap as direction only.
Finally, hunt early in the morning and hold on to quiet ground. Have your setup ready before first light. If a top morning is quiet on ground that held birds earlier, log a low gobbling day and keep that ground in your rotation.
The studies measured gobbles. None measured a hunter's chance of killing a turkey.
Season dates and legal shooting hours differ by state, so check your state wildlife agency before planning around any opener.
NOTES AND SOURCES
- Source: Wightman and colleagues 2022, Ecology and Evolution, open access, influence of weather on gobbling activity of male wild turkeys.
- Also: Wightman and colleagues 2019 and Wakefield and colleagues 2020 in the Journal of Wildlife Management, Chamberlain and colleagues 2018 in the Wildlife Society Bulletin, Palumbo and colleagues 2019 in the International Journal of Biometeorology, Lehman and colleagues in the Proceedings of the National Wild Turkey Symposium, and University of Georgia theses by Colbert and by Wakefield.
- Scope: Gobbling counted by recorders on public and federal properties in South Carolina and Georgia, a statewide Mississippi gobbling survey, and listening routes in the Black Hills of South Dakota.
- Method: Figures are as printed in the papers and theses. The Wakefield 2020, Chamberlain 2018 and Palumbo 2019 papers were read as abstracts only. The percent drop with rain, unit conversions and the point ratios behind our ranking rule were computed by FDR.
- Limits: Every recorder study here comes from Georgia or South Carolina, so hunters farther north are working from Southeast numbers.
- Limits: Rain also muffles recorders, so part of the rain effect is likely birds that gobbled and went unrecorded.
- Limits: The rain and hunting effects come from different models, so compare them by direction only.
- Limits: These studies counted gobbles and none of them measured a hunter's chance of killing a bird.
Fully Drawn Research is an independent data analysis desk, not affiliated with any state wildlife agency, transportation agency, mapping provider or outfitter. Fully Drawn Research is an independent data and analysis desk. This paper summarizes published research and adds FDR's reading of what it means for hunters. Figures are quoted from the studies linked in the text, and figures we computed from them are labeled as ours.
Keep reading
FDR Scout puts research like this on the map of the ground you hunt. Open Scout →See the plans →