In the Kerr Wildlife Management Area pens in Texas, the mean gross antler score at age 4.5 was 89.9 inches for bucks that had been spikes as yearlings versus 127.8 inches for bucks that had been forked yearlings. On south Texas ranches where 11 of 12 were high-fenced and fed, yearlings carrying at most 3 points scored 306.8 cm at age 4.5 versus 314.7 cm among yearlings carrying at least 4 points without a statistically significant difference.
IDifferent Outcomes
Kerr Spikes Stayed Behind but Ranch Yearlings Closed the Difference
Of the papers we reviewed only Kerr shows a lasting gap. We think the argument for culling spikes depends mainly on that single penned herd. Koerth and Kroll say their ranch findings agree with research from Mississippi and a pen study from Louisiana. Neither paper was among those we read.
IIPenned Bucks
Kerr's Forked Yearlings Averaged 127.8 Inches Versus 89.9 Among Spikes
Ott's team examined records from 140 bucks born between 1973 and 1990 in a captive Texas herd with known pedigrees at Kerr Wildlife Management Area. Bucks qualified only with full antler records for ages 1.5 and 4.5. The deer occupied 1.62-hectare pens with free-choice access to a ration containing 16% crude protein. The yearling groups contained 43 spikes and 97 forked bucks.
By age 4.5 the average for forked bucks was 127.8 inches with a standard error of 2.0 versus 89.9 inches with a standard error of 2.8 among spikes. The groups differed by 38 inches with P below 0.001. At that age only 2.3% of spikes topped 120 inches versus 62% of bucks that had been forked yearlings.
Yearlings bearing at least 6 points averaged 134.0 inches by age 4.5 compared with 114.6 inches among bucks bearing 3 to 5 points as yearlings. Ott and colleagues said spike-antlered bucks "continued to produce smaller antlers at maturity in our controlled population."
IIIRanch Follow-Up
Bucks Starting With at Most 3 Points Caught Up by Age 4.5
Koerth and Kroll relied on helicopter net guns to capture wild whitetail bucks on 12 ranches in south Texas spanning 5 counties between 1999 and 2007. They say every ranch except one had high fences and the ranches grew oats, used corn feeders and supplied pelleted feed year-round. They tagged bucks and caught them again when possible before taking final measurements following legal harvest. They kept only deer initially marked as fawns or yearlings because they consider tooth-wear aging reliable at those ages (known-age tests appear in FDR's guide to tooth ages). To fit Texas antler point restrictions they divided yearlings into bucks carrying at most 3 points and bucks carrying at least 4 points. Spikes shared the lower group with 3-pointers.
Gross scores initially ran lower among bucks starting with at most 3 points. Their averages were 194.1 cm versus 238.5 cm by age 2.5 and 264.4 cm versus 287.8 cm by age 3.5. By age 4.5 scores were 306.8 cm versus 314.7 cm (P = 0.320).
For bucks reaching age 4.5 or beyond the share scoring 330 cm or higher was 47.7% among yearlings carrying at most 3 points (31 of 65). The authors identify that score as the area's long-term average. For yearlings carrying at least 4 points the share reached 48.1% (39 of 81). At the 381 cm trophy mark the shares were 10 of 65 (15.4%) versus 10 of 81 (12.3%).
The paper leaves unclear how many individual bucks occur in multiple age classes. Group sizes fell from 180 and 166 at age 2.5 to 41 and 49 at age 4.5. The authors also checked whether culling might explain their finding. Among culled bucks yearling point counts weakly predicted scores at age 2.5 (r-squared 0.211 from 49 deer) and age 3.5 (r-squared 0.093 from 45 deer) but did not predict scores at age 4.5 (P = 0.608 from 35 deer).
Swipe table to see every column
| Study | Deer and place | Yearling groups | Adult score at 4.5 years |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ott and colleagues 1997 | 140 bucks in pens at Kerr, 1973 to 1990, 16% protein feed | Spike (43 bucks) and forked (97 bucks) | 89.9 and 127.8 gross inches |
| Koerth and Kroll 2008 | Marked south Texas ranch deer, 1999 to 2007 | 3 or fewer points (41 bucks) and 4 or more points (49 bucks) | 306.8 and 314.7 gross cm |
IVRelated Work
Other Papers Describe Mississippi and Louisiana Pens Matching the Ranch Result
For every statement here we rely on the paper describing it because we did not read either the Mississippi or Louisiana papers. Koerth and Kroll describe their ranch findings as consistent with results from Lukefahr and Jacobson (1998) and Schultz and Johnson (1992). They describe those studies as finding weak correlations between yearling point counts and mature antler size. They also say Lukefahr and Jacobson found that Mississippi yearling spikes were unreliable indicators of potential antler growth. Ott and colleagues call the Mississippi animals a captive herd. In Ott and colleagues' account of Schultz and Johnson's captive Louisiana deer the antler-mass gap between spike and forked yearlings narrowed by age 4.5. Ott and colleagues report that the captive Louisiana sample shrank from 20 spikes to 6 and from 53 forked yearlings to 13. Gray and colleagues say no differences could be detected by age 4.5.
A subsequent captive-deer study from Michel's team found moderate to high heritability in antler traits. Using 1.5-year-old antler size alone gave only a moderate prediction of size at age 3.5. We read the abstract alone and it says adding birth date and litter size nearly doubled predictability.
VFawn Timing
Alabama Spike Births Averaged About 27 Days After Forked Yearling Births
Gray's team examined 677 bucks killed as yearlings on 23 wildlife management areas in Alabama during 1998 to 99 as well as 1999 to 2000. They used tooth eruption to estimate birth dates and say that method had not been tested in free-ranging deer. Average births fell on 26 June among forked yearlings and 23 July among spikes. Bucks born during April or May were forked at a rate of 49.1% versus 17.5% among those born from September to November. Gray and colleagues did not track any deer beyond its yearling year.
We think an extended fawning season may leave some spikes younger than others in their age class and those deer may still have growing ahead. Kerr's paper lists no buck birth dates. According to Ott and colleagues their finding applies to Texas deer fed a high-quality diet. Koerth and Kroll caution that findings are hard to extend to wild deer when the studied animals were confined "at unnaturally high densities, and fed a high-quality diet ad libitum."
Our rule is not to cull a yearling with at most 3 points solely because of his first antlers. Those yearlings hit 330 cm as often in the ranch study as bucks carrying at least 4 points, with shares of 47.7% versus 48.1%. Kerr's pens remain the exception within mixed evidence, which leaves us treating this as a judgment call rather than settled science. Hunter-killed yearlings are covered in FDR's paper on yearling bucks in the harvest.
VIEvidence Boundaries
A Single Pen Herd and Ranch Study Leave Other Papers Unread
The Kerr finding comes from a single Texas herd containing 140 bucks from 1973 to 1990 fed a single diet. All had full records through age 4.5. The ranch study covered 11 ranches with high fences and 1 ranch with low fences. Deer received feed at every ranch. Koerth and Kroll put yearlings carrying at most 3 points together without reporting spikes separately. That keeps us from saying what results ranch spikes by themselves would have given. Alabama's birth-date estimates came from teeth. For Michel and colleagues we saw the abstract alone and the Mississippi and Louisiana papers went unread. None of the studies tested whether killing spikes changes herd antler size over generations or tracked yearlings that hunters deliberately passed.
NOTES AND SOURCES
- Source: Ott and colleagues 1997, Proceedings of the Annual Conference of the Southeastern Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies 51, spike and fork-antlered yearling white-tailed deer of the Kerr Wildlife Management Area pen herd at maturity.
- Also: Koerth and Kroll 2008, Journal of Wildlife Management 72(5), antler development of wild bucks recaptured on south Texas ranches. Gray and colleagues 2002, Proceedings of the Southeastern Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies 56, birth dates of spike and forked yearlings in Alabama. Michel and colleagues 2016, Journal of Wildlife Management 80(8).
- Scope: 140 penned Kerr bucks born 1973 to 1990, wild bucks captured on 12 south Texas ranches in 5 counties from 1999 to 2007 (11 of the 12 ranches high-fenced, with fed deer), and 677 yearling bucks killed on 23 Alabama wildlife management areas in the 1998 to 99 and 1999 to 2000 seasons.
- Method: Scores are as printed. Kerr and ranch scores are both gross antler scores, in inches for Kerr and in centimeters for the ranches, and the two are never compared. The ranch study grouped yearlings with 3 or fewer points against 4 or more. Mississippi and Louisiana results are described only as Ott and colleagues and Koerth and Kroll report them. Michel and colleagues was read as an abstract.
- Limits: The Kerr result comes from one pen herd on a 16% protein diet. The ranch study compared yearlings with 3 or fewer points against 4 or more, not spikes against forks.
- Limits: The Michel and colleagues study was read as an abstract only, and the Mississippi and Louisiana papers were not read.
- Limits: No study read tested whether shooting spikes changes antler size over generations.
Fully Drawn Research is an independent data analysis desk, not affiliated with any state wildlife agency, transportation agency, mapping provider or outfitter. Fully Drawn Research is an independent data and analysis desk. This paper summarizes published research and adds FDR's reading of what it means for hunters. Figures are quoted from the studies linked in the text, and figures we computed from them are labeled as ours.
Keep reading
FDR Scout puts county harvest history like this on the map of the ground you hunt. Open Scout →See the plans →